暨南大学 “‘每月一译’ 翻译之星” 2019年4月点评

发布者:陈子微发布时间:2019-04-28浏览次数:1766


作者:林巍




【原文】

开始写作


[1] 我开始写小说,是在进了女师的第二年,那时刚满十五岁。[2] 有一天,我和两位小学时代的同学,去一个同乡家里吃饭,主人刚刚买了一个十三岁的丫头来,那女孩长得面黄肌瘦,身材短小,满脸现着泪痕;倒是一双乌溜溜的大眼睛,非常惹人怜爱。[3]女主人是一位师长太太,她命令女孩走路给我们看,并请我们批评她的一举一动的姿势,是否合于一个师长公馆用的丫头。[4] 那两位同学真的将视线集中在女孩的身上;可是我的眼里却正燃烧着不平的火焰!我恨那位女主人太不人道了,简直把人当做畜生看,我当时气得饭也吃不下,借故回到学校,立刻写了一篇《刹那的印象》。


  

【点评】

  

 就格式而言,尽管已多次提醒,但仍有很多不按要求做的,故只能视其为废稿,没有成绩。

 本文节选自著名现代作家谢冰莹的一篇回忆文章,虽寥寥几笔,但形象生动,有真情实感。

关于题目 —“开始写作”,参赛者大都译成了 Begin Writing/Started Writing / The Beginning of My Writing Journey / Initiate of writing 等,其实这里讲了一个小故事,说明作者自己是如何开始写作的,故不妨译为:How I Start to Write

[1] 中,“女师”指的是女子师范学校,似可译成Union Normal School for Womenthe Women's Normal schoolWomen Teacher’s Training School 等,但更为通俗的,可为the Female Teachers School。但在行文中,有的译得过于“零碎”,如I started writing novels, and I was in the second year of entering the female teacher, when I was just fifteen years old. / I was just fifteen years old when I decided to write novel, the second year I studied in Women’s Normal School./ It was on my second year in the women’s normal school that I started to write a novel, when I was just fifteen years old.等。原文固然是三句,但根据英文形合的特点,可用介词、代词等连成一句,如:I began to write novels in my second year at the Female Teachers School when I was just fifteen years old.

[2] 中,同乡是一个很宽泛的概念,可指来自同一个村、县城、省市的认识或不认识的人,英文可有countrymenfellowfellow townsman等,鉴于作者那时是个小学生,可译为fellow student“丫头”是那时做佣人女孩子的一种称呼,可为 servant girl; 对于“面黄肌瘦,身材短小,满脸现着泪痕”不宜“一一对应”,如who had a thin face, a short figure and tears all over her face / She was short and slight in build, with a tear-stained face that showed an air of sickness 等,而可概述为 She was small, thin, emaciated with sallow complexion; 非常惹人怜爱似不必单句译成but her a pair of big, black eyes were very affectionate / attractive , 而可与前面“大眼睛”相结合,译成bigadorable black eyes。故此,整句不妨译为:One day, I, together with my two primary school classmates, went to a fellow student’s home to eat. The hostess, a teacher’s wife, had just bought a 13-year-old servant girl. She was small, thin, emaciated with sallow complexion but a pair of big adorable black eyes.

[3]中,比较典型的参赛译文,如As the wife of a division commander, the hostess ordered the girl to walk for us guests to see whether the way the girl walk match her family status before we criticizing on that. / The hostess was a teacher’s wife in Woman’s Normal School. She orders the girl to show us her position to walk. Then asked us to judge the girl’ s position of her gait. Therefore, we can judge the girl is available or not to be a mad in the residence of hostess’s house. / The hostess, the teacher's wife, ordered the girl to walk and show us. Moreover, she asked us to criticize her every move and gesture, whether it was suitable for a girl of the master's residence. 等,意思似乎译出来了,但某些词语和表述不够准确(下划线标出)。其中,“师长”是旧时教师的尊称,“师长太太”(a teacher’s wife)已在前面译出, 此处可省略,“走路给我们看”就是摆posture; “是否合于,即是否符合……的标准,而这里的“批评”不是一般意义上的criticize, 且宜结合下面的内容译出。故此,该句不妨译为 The hostess ordered her to walk and posture to show us whether she fit the criteria to be a girl serving in the teacher’s mansion.

[4] 中,其中有些语意、语气的转合。对于“将视线集中在……身上”参赛者一般译成The two classmates really focused on the girl / the two classmates actually put their eyes on her / those two classmates of mine did fix their eyes upon the girl 等,固然没有错,但根据上文说的“批评”,此处应有所体现,即可意译为 In forming their judgment, 以产生语境上的衔接;把人当做畜生看不宜照字面意思译成looked at people as animalstreat people as animals / I hated the hostess for being so inhuman that she treated people like animals / I held an intense grudge against the inhumanity of the hostess who went so far as to regard human as brutes 等,而可通述为treating people with indignity, 在句子中作主语, “我当时气得饭也吃不下,是对比她同学的态度而言的,可用verb + object + adjective — that的句式译出: … made me so angry that I found it difficult to eat anything;  “借故,可另起一句为On an excuse; “刹那的印象,一般译成了Momentary Impression / The sudden impression /Impression of the Moment,而 flash 在此似更确切,该词的本义为a sudden brilliant understanding故此段不妨译为:In forming their judgment, my two classmates mainly concentrated on the girl’s body; my eyes, however, burned with a flame for the injustice. I hated the hostess, and her inhuman way of treating people with indignity made me so angry that I found it difficult to eat anything. On an excuse, I went back to school and immediately wrote a piece of work entitled The Flash on My Mind.

   总之,翻译中词语的选择和句式的表述,既要尊重字典上的涵义,又要根据具体语境作灵活的变通。



参考译文

How I Start to Write

  

[1] I began to write novels in my second year at the Female Teachers School when I was just fifteen years old.

[2] One day, I, together with my two primary school classmates, went to a fellow student’s home to eat. The hostess, a teacher’s wife, had just bought a 13-year-old servant girl. She was small, thin, emaciated with sallow complexion but a pair of big adorable black eyes.

[3] The hostess ordered her to walk and posture to show us whether she fit the criteria to be a girl serving in the teacher’s mansion.

[4] In forming their judgment, my two classmates mainly concentrated on the girl’s body; my eyes, however, burned with a flame for the injustice. I hated the hostess, and her inhuman way of treating people with indignity made me so angry that I found it difficult to eat anything. On an excuse, I went back to school and immediately wrote a piece of work entitled The Flash on My Mind.